The closely divided Senate Banking and Financial Institutions committee voted 3-3 yesterday afternoon. Because of the tie, the bill failed to pass.

Proponents of the measure argue on a micro scale for the individual homeowner who is deeply underwater, maybe trying to get a loan mod and/or is facing foreclosure. Opponents of the measure argue on a macro scale that the measure merely delays the inevitable cleansing of financially weak homeowners who can’t afford their homes, thus delaying an increasingly stubborn housing recovery.

As usual, there is merit in both positions.But for now, it would appear the current process of dual-track will continue.